The Gouge Cover Photo v2

During a crisis, “sit on your hands”

tomcat crash

Twenty-six years ago, on a clear Spring afternoon, an F-14 Tomcat took off from a USMC air base in North Carolina. Within seconds after takeoff, the aircrew knew something was wrong with their engines when the jet struggled to climb. After a glance at the engine instruments, the pilot quickly shut down the engine he believed was damaged.

Unfortunately, he secured the wrong motor, leaving a 66,000-pound Tomcat airborne with only a single, failing engine. As the jet fell out of the sky, the pilot steered the wounded Tomcat toward an unpopulated patch of woods, and both aircrew ejected. They survived without injury, but the jet was destroyed. Just twenty seconds had passed from takeoff to plane crash.

A USMC AV-8B Harrier, which was sequenced to takeoff next, watched the entire event and later reported to mishap-investigators that he observed a long flame emanating from one of the Tomcat’s two engines as soon as the takeoff roll started. He was also transparent in saying that he took no action to inform the Tomcat crew.

A catastrophic engine failure, such as what happened with the Tomcat, is without question a pilot’s most dire emergency. An aircraft that is low, slow, and heavy with only half of the available thrust requires swift decision-making and precise action to keep it airborne. But acting swiftly and precisely in accordance with written procedures does not equate to acting ‘lightning fast’ and possibly short-changing analysis or missing a critical step.

An engine that is catastrophically failing can cause additional aircraft damage, so shutting it down as soon as possible is a necessity. Naval aviators are trained to “sit on your hands for a few potatoes,” meaning they should not to touch anything while they wait for a few seconds (“one potato…two potato…) to assess before taking a potentially irreversible and costly action. The Navy Nuclear Propulsion Community employs a similar expression for the hand movements of control panel operators: “No cobra strikes.”

Had the Tomcat pilot waited a few more potatoes, I wonder if he might’ve had a better diagnosis. To be clear, this is not criticism of the pilot. Seconds away from dying, he fought the “snakes in the cockpit” the best he could, made an assessment, and acted. It’s important to remind oneself that no one was injured in this circumstance, but the loss of aircraft was preventable. It’s also important to imagine how this could have ended up way worse, especially for people on the ground

I am still stunned that the Harrier pilot who witnessed a 40-foot flame coming out one of the Tomcat engine said nothing on the control-tower frequency. I know Marines are the strong, silent types but this was not time to be silent (Marines are always strong). A simple warning like, “Tomcat lifting Cherry Point, it appears your right engine is putting out an extremely long, unnatural flame…you are welcome” would’ve been useful information for the aircrew to have.

The lesson for readers is to take your time with critical or emotional decisions. You may want to act ‘lightning fast,’ but you’ll probably miss critical pieces along the way.   

It’s OK to briefly “sit on your hands” during a crisis. To take an unofficial lesson from this below average biology teacher, when your blood pressure rises, your brain has the potential to temporarily shrink to the size of a primordial pea and inhibit critical thinking skills …so, please, take a breath. Count a few potatoes. Assess, and then take action. You may find that those few moments of “sitting on your hands” will help you calmly process bad or surprising news.

If you see someone on fire… for the love of God, SAY SOMETHING. Saying nothing is inexcusable. In other words, don’t be like that Harrier pilot. 

It’s also OK to bite your tongue. This gouge also applies to verbal interactions. If you are about to viscerally respond to a co-worker who just ticked you off, you have power to bite your tongue, count your potatoes, and think about whether what you want to say is really what needs to be said.

Show them you care!